Ck2 wrong type of holding tribal 500KG. This brings me to in interesting "problem" regarding "wrong holding type": I've started a game as a duke in Sweden in 1066 and had a de jure claim on gotland. - Fleet size . So they can't convert to my government type because they're not of my government type. A noble is someone whose first holding is a castle, a mayor someone whose first holding They will get a relations penalty for wrong government type but will give you vassal troops like a normal feudal vassal. But I'm not sure of the cost in Wrong holding type has nothing to do with culture. I gave away the bishopric that I took over, but I still have it and it says that the Chiefdom of Gwynedd is the wrong holding type for me. So for example if you're personally holding say a Republic (City) or Theocracy (Temple) while You aren't supposed to directly hold cities or temples as a feudal lord. Which means you will Instead I stupidly gave it to the Duke and now he gives me -30 relations hit because of wrong holding. Converting government types in Crusader Kings 2 can be a complex process but can bring substantial benefits. So far I have no penalties for holding them but that is due to the 2 month honeymoon period before penalties. Now he is tribal, and will stay tribal when he inherit other title. " Currently, CK3 uses the same three holding types (for non-tribal areas) as CK2 did: castles, cities and temples, which are tied to monarchical, republican and theocratic governments respectively. You will be able to revoke his previous holdings from him and he will remain tribal. You just need a tribal government (who directly owns the county) to build a tribal holding. Each form of government has preferred and allowed settlements, and will get "Wrong government type" ( "Wrong Holding Type" means you're holding a title which is a different government from you. I can make it my capital, but I don't really want to make my capital in mainland Britannia with the rest of my holdings in Ireland. CK2 I’m new to the game and just recently conquered all of Ireland but Ithcar Connachta is labeled as the wrong holding type since the county capital is a temple is there a way to change it to something else? Could someone explain to me whatd up with holdings, specifically when it says wrong holding type. I have managed to give it away, thanks for the tip. since this two types would be of the wrong government type you should give them away to maximize levies and money the better a castle you will get (most tribal holdings increase at a 2:1 ratio for related castle buildings. They are one of four major settlement types, the other three being castles, cities and tribes. However, there are several things about this Back in CK2 tier 4 tribal buildings were converted into tier 2 feudal, allowing us to carefully plan and have a somewhat smooth transition, but in my current game I quickly went feudal when I noticed all tech were locked if I didn't and my tribal buildings got converted into dirt. Wrong type of holding in demesne ck2 'Invite a Holy Men to the court') to create new random characters. Lemme try it out in Nice. Give your husband a county and press for a duchy and you end up with a duke vassal. Has this changed in CK3? The reason for this is the large penalty associated with owning a holding of the wrong type; you lose out on 75% of the income of the holding. You pick the realm with the best development or technology as your capital. I started a run as Mantarys, which is feudal, and by the time I’d formed North Valyria, Volantis had collapsed. This allows you as a tribal ruler to conquer feudal/republican counties, build a tribe in it and make it the primary holding to avoid the 'wrong holding type'-malus whilst still keeping the county in your demesne. Hovewer, it is always good to control counties directly since you c Crusader Kings 2 How To Change From Tribal To Feudal. I am listed as the holder of the city of Newark, so I keep getting the "wrong type of holding" alert. It isn't listed as one of my demesnes that I can assign to someone else. But I now have a county with a wooden castle and I've got the Wrong Type of Holding warning. its not that bad. A Character's type is determined by the type of his or her first holding. In Crusader Kings 2, there are eight levels of technology. But I can't give it away. City holdings cannot be effectively held by characters with clan governments and will provide no taxes or levies. My main holding is still tribal but I took over a province that was feudal with a castle as its main holding and now it's telling me that I have a wrong type of holding. Give me depth. ) Tribal There are 3 character types - feudal, burgher, and bishop. The main ways you can go wrong are: [CK2] Which type of holding is best? On my Brittania game, I've got a stupid amount of money, and want to build some holdings. 8/24/2023 This is directly reflected in the effects of each level: As you can see, if your liege was non-Tribal with Limited Tribal Authority, you’d be able to convert to Feudal or Clan. 1) You need to have an empty holding slot 2) (Haven't verified but it's how it worked in CK 2) To build a holding type that is already present in the county the county must already have at least one of each holding type present. No crown authority. Ck2 Wrong Type Of Holding. CrUsHeR. As Tominsocal notes, you can grant the county You won't be able to give it to anyone who already has a tribal holding. Wrong Holding Type There are three types of holdings in the game, castles, cities, and temples. Support me on patreon : https://www. however lots of my vassals hate me now because they have the wrong government type. Have your heir with a higher tier title than your own. e. Last edited by Karlington; Jun 13, 2019 @ 7:50pm #8. Game Version 1. Corresponding to this there are three types of characters, nobles, mayors, and priests. If a character owns an additional holding that is of a different type from this first holding, he or she will get the wrong holding type penalty on that holding. It's also worth noting that there are (at least) three other ways to solve the "wrong holding type" problem, in addition to the one you describe. The reason for this is the large penalty associated with owning a holding of the wrong type you lose out on 75 of the income of the holding. So i saved for some mercs and successfully pressed my claim. 60 x 400 gold = no thanks. Special decisions allow tribes and nomads to become more 'settled. In this case, Ragnvald is the mayor of a city, and we're the lord of a castle. 1. I then So I am trying to learn CK2 by following an old LP I was reading, and after invading a county in Ireland, winning the war, and gaining title to the county I have a 'wrong holding type' malus for the county. All my Vassals were pissed because of "Wrong Government Type" The "gogo Feudalism"-event button was still around. Apart from that, doesn't really matter if Temples are the generic name for religious holdings in a county. You're not getting penalized for having the wrong government type, you're just not getting the bonus for empty holding slots that a tribal ruler would get. Depends on what type of Holding it is. I. ) Doing this while you are a tribe is recommended because the buildings only In CK2, feudal rulers (including iqta, monastic feudal, Imperial, etc) can only hold tribal titles of their own culture without penalty. So what is the penalty for being feudal while holding a The main holding, Ravenna, is a Temple. in this one as lithuania tribal there are none to raid, neighbours are the same poor b*tards. Keep all count vassals imprisoned, so they cannot join factions or plot against you. Is it possible to change this city into a castle so the wrong holding type penalty will disappear? You can only replace the tribe if: you control the county; and you personally own the tribe; and there are no empty holding slots in the county. Apparently the vassal was a fuedal, I guess. Running the most updated version 2. I don't know why it's there because I have other In my opinion, the biggest thing holding CK2 back is this insatiable lust to build wider. īeing a republic I conquered some tribal holdings in the North via holy war and, noticing the 'wrong type of holding' penalty, granted these to some of my middle sons and other relatives. No longer allowed to land eunuchs with feudal holdings - Fixed a bug preventing a complete victory against a landless enemy with only fleets. The same thing happened 100 years ago when I was king of just Ireland and teld on to Beanaomh About managing Prestige: Yes, there's the Tribal Army option but if you are to stay Tribal for an extended period of time (which you totally should btw, rushing Feudalism will just leave you with very few useful holdings and a bunch of rebellious vassals might as well milk Tribal for the free, aka prestige-bought, buildings!) so if you are to stay tribal for longer, you should invest your I conquered some tribal holdings in the North via holy war and, noticing the 'wrong type of holding' penalty, granted these to some of my middle sons and other relatives. Or he can die and leave all tribal untouched holdings AND gold to tribal heir. For example, if the primary holding of one of the counties in you demense is a castle (because you are a noble) you can grant your county title to a bishop in that county to make his cathedral the primary holding. While merc gold won't make you too strong, having money in your stashes can certainly help. patreon. This means that tax-wise it cannot pay off to hold a holding of the wrong type rather than one of the right type. Mar 25, 2022 @ 12:23pm No, that isn't possible. But it says wrong type of holding. This method of It is 882 AD and I am the King of Ireland and Scotland. Forum list Trending. Welcome to the ck2 community. The wrong type of holding is a big hit in taxes, a lessser one in manpower, so as a tribal keeping them in your hands for a while may be worthwile, specially castles and/or cities for the time you want to upgrade out of tribal. Report. You could revoke the castle holding or build a new castle holding which would automatically make that the capital holding. First CK2 Post. Republics aren't the worst though, they generally Wrong settlement type [edit | edit source] Characters get a 75% penalty to income and levies in demesne settlements that do not match their government type. The window suggests that there aren’t any current holdings, and the requirements state that I should be able to, but when I actually go to build a tribe or a temple, I am unable to do so. Either way don't panic about the penalty that much. The naming scheme is "Holding name - Province name". ) switch governments temporarily Or 2. If you still don’t restrain yourself, you will get severe penalties in the shape of zero tax and minimal levies. Vassal limit penalties now applies first after Ck2 wrong holding type penalty. Hey, Duke, right click and then choose the left-most option, dude! Toggle signature Therefore the system of "wrong type" is a little confusing according to the historical practice. Crusader Kings is a historical grand strategy / RPG game series for PC, Mac, Linux, PlayStation 5 & Xbox Series X|S developed & published by Paradox Development Studio. Not sure what to do with it. Once you start moving from tribal into feudal, you need to start Can someone please explain "Wrong Type of Holding in Demesne" to me :( And how I can change this? Long story short, I was ruling as the king of Ireland but my character "Wrong type of holding" refers to you directly holding a city or bishopric. Thanks in Ck2 wrong type of holding in demesne. Eg: Only Bishops can rule Churches, if you grant ownership of a Church to a Mayor, it's the wrong holding. #1. Bedford has a castle and I'm still tribal. The work around I found is if you have the option to increase to authority level 3 available and have enough prestige you can use the switch character option in the pause menu and switch to a vassal in your kingdom then wait about a month or so and a notification should pop up in the bottom right about your liege (your original character) had a Ck2 wrong holding type. How do you convert the holdings? There are three minor decisions for each holding type. And slowly develope to feudal\republic. I'm having an issue whenever I adopt feudalism. value of a tribal holding depends Destroy Holding is available for Tribal rulers who also directly owns Feudal-type holdings like Castles, Cities or Temples. about it I came across one wiki that mentions burghers and nobles and the problems you might have if you assign the wrong type to a holding. Since then i took over the rest of the area around the Baltic and my vassals are expanding me down into Russia/Poland. We're getting a shallow ocean when we need a deep lake. If your primary holding is a castle, you are feudal and all other holding types (temple, city, tribe) are considered wrong holding. If you choose to save up this prestige until you get 5000, you can also use the revolts to easily forge a bloodline via ambition, as Destroy Holding is available for Tribal rulers who also directly owns Feudal-type holdings like Castles, Cities or Temples. I know i can change the tribe into a castle but i dont see the option to change it into a The government model of castle/city/temple or feudal/republic/theocracy is what it is. So im still not understanding this right. Thanks in Advanced tips and tricks for beginners - Updated 2022! Top rated CK2 Steam Guide of all time! As a side note, whilst discussing minor titles, if ever you conquer a new county and get the notification 'wrong type of holding', it means that you (a feudal lord) are holding a secondary title (city or church). Reply reply Aztlantic In my experience buildings are amazing. Problem is, my vassals have a bunch of tribal holdings that they aren't upgrading to feudal, which basically makes hey so im playing as saxony, reformed the germanic religion and became feudal. was still tribal, and unable to feudalise despite owning 3 counties with Wrong settlement type [edit | edit source] Characters get a 75% penalty to income and levies in demesne settlements that do not match their government type. It's essentially necessary to convert in the long-run for realm stability, to get rid of gavelkind and start developing your holdings. There are several ways to change government type during the game. Each form of government has preferred and allowed settlements, and will get 'Wrong government type' (-75 levies and income) penalty while holding other types of settlements directly. You also work to convert and settle that realm asap. Either give them away to a mayor or bishop or create a new such vassal by right-clicking that settlement The solutions are either getting the right type of holding to be the county capital, either by building a new holding of the correct type or revoking the title of another holding of So far I have no penalties for holding them but that is due to the 2 month honeymoon period before penalties. 5 for a tribe, 4 for a castle, 8 for a temple, or 12 for a city. You have to give it to a new vassal who isn't already tribal, which makes him pissed at you for having the wrong gov't type. So where did it go wrong? This means that tax-wise it cannot pay off to hold a holding of the wrong type rather than one of the right type. com/index. Sounds like you're tribal and the holding is feudal. So I'm still Norse tribal (Rurik decendent) and revoked one of my vassal's titles after he resisted arrest and he raised his flag. 1. Fixed an issue with newly activated titles getting the wrong government type - Non-pagan Temple type characters no longer inherit claims - Added new ambition: 'Become King of X'. You need just 1 vassal of the correct government, Or 1 holding of the correct type to Wrong Holding Type Description In 1178, Count Bard of Naumdalafylki is Feudal, but the only Holding he holds is a Tribal Holding. I was playing as Matilda. I heard that it is because that the guy has like the wrong building in his county according to his title. Once the tribal is finished building it will automatically become top holding of the county since it's Destroy Holding is available for Tribal rulers who also directly owns Feudal-type holdings like Castles, Cities or Temples. I think, legally, that it is possible to convert to a different government type. It dictates the available succession laws and holdings of a character, and some government types have unique mechanics. If you want to change individual baronies, then the only way to do that would be to pillage the baronies until they are razed to the ground and then rebuilding whatever you want instead. So what I do is go to the character finder, filter on my religion, my culture, male, ruler. You can build a tribal holding in a county that has other types of holdings, such as castles, cities or churches. The tribal holding is more powerful the more empty holdings there are, as adding castles or temples reduced the amount of land available to the tribe. WC comments sorted by Best Top New Controversial Q&A Add a Comment [deleted] • Additional comment actions Then once inside you're going to find the wrong holding penalty and change that to zero Thanks! I wonder if there's any benefit to going Tribal first, instead of straight to Feudal. 6. ) let vassals upgrade the holdings from tribes to castles/cities. Most important thing is to make sure that all of your holdings + all those of your direct vassals have level 4 hillforts so that they can become castles, otherwise they will still be tribal and have -30 opinion for wrong government type. A large part of your income, especially in a small realm, comes from the personal holdings of your demesne. paradoxwikis. I am an independent unreformed Pagan tribal ruler and when I give an unlanded tribal courtier a city or a temple, their government changes to the correct type, but when I give them a castle they stay tribal (and have the wrong holding type penalty). Thing is, the button that normally lets you create a proper type vassal is grayed out. Have a revolt risk modifier until the culture shift to norse and then have the holding change to a tribe rather than a castle. Finally, the Wrong Government Type penalty occurs when a higher ranked (count or above) vassal is ruled by a liege with a different holding type. You're going to suffer from the 'Wrong government' opinion malus for that particular vassal, but it's still better than holding on to it yourself. 2 Platform Windows Additional Information Affected Feature Crashes; Gameplay; Save Game it is probably not possible to remove a holding, or is it? the reason why i ask is because i recently accuired a new county but the ai already has filled it with temple holdings (and possibly another city but i'm not sure if that was built or if it was there from the beginning), which i would like to change to a more balanced number of castles, cities and temples. 3, I own all the DLC's and have them all loaded save Conclave. I'm not entirely sure as I've only played as a Feudal character, but when Feudal provinces in my game were conquered by Tribes they sprouted new Tribe holdings. Keep in mind that you need to have Tribal Organization maxed out to become a Merchant Republic; since you're going to use the Isle of Man, you'll start as a duchy-level ruler so you don't have to wait to create a title first but it'll still take you twenty years of game time to do that since the first jump can be made immediately after the game begins. This dictates which types of holdings they can have in their demesne without having a "wrong holding type" penalty, which gives -75% income to a holding. Best way to fix it is to give it away to someone who isn't already a ruler. If your king lead a town/church, you get a wrong type of holding message, and you also get a -75% penalty from stuffs. Give your heir tribe, then one of your top titles (he will be independent). if the county doesn't already have a castle, temple, and city you can't build a second castle. Steps to reproduce Enter the game in 1178, and you will see it. Tribal Soverign And Wrong Government Type With Vassals, Any Each province comprises one or more holdings led by a character (either player or AI) and are the source of levies and taxes. Then give the respective county to the baron. Nineteenth-century theologian Friedrich Schleiermacher defined it as 'that which preserved the appearance of Christianity, and yet contradicted its essence'. Level 0 is 700 AD technology, Level 1 is 800 AD Feb 17, 2012 The most mayor friendly laws give a net relations penalty of -10 (-30 wrong gov, +20 laws). The cities have a little exclamation mark over the rectangle that displays the holding type. Wrong Holding Type Description In 1178, Count Bard of Naumdalafylki is Feudal, but the only Holding he holds is a Tribal Holding. All of this can leave you exposed if you have stronger neighbors with Welcome to the ck2 community. value of a tribal holding depends I sat "eventually" because when you first convert your government your levies will be reduced significantly while your tribal holdings rebuild into castles. #8. Tribal has better CBs for taking large territory but Nomad has even better ones, so it seems like you'd just want to stay nomad until you're mostly done conquering and then turn Feudal. The tribal leader relies more on prestige for troops and workers than he necessarily needs gold. As of the Monks and Mystics Expansion version, there were 4,457 holdings in the world in 1066, with potential for up to 5,190. (Note: the last 2 bullet points no longer work with the latest patches as you cannot build multiple tribal holdings in one county and get crippling penalties for wrong holding type. Ģ) The game is both more and less CK2 I’m new to the game and just recently conquered all of Ireland but Ithcar Connachta is labeled as the wrong holding type since the county capital is a temple is there a way to change it to something else? Could someone explain to me whatd up with holdings, specifically when it says wrong holding type. You can rectify this by going to Help! This bs relationticker is killing my kingdom. You probably want a couple of castles so you have baronies to hand out to people with good inheritable traits, but beyond that, if you’re going theocratic then the best thing to do is spam temples because they produce the most taxes and levies and have the easiest-to-manage title holders, by a wide margin. When you mouse over this warning it states: "Wrong type of holding. " County claims and you're a duke, count or duke claims and you're a king, etc. You can change the primary holding type by granting the county title to a baron/mayor/bishop character in that county. They are not the right type of holding. Feudal characters can hold castles, burghers can hold cities, and bishops can hold churches. At this setting you're still getting 15% of the county's income in tax, vs 10% for a count vassal with the same -10% relations penalty due to laws. So "Lukomorie (Zaporozhie)" means the province is Lukomorie and its holding is the Lukomorie Tribe, but if converted to a town or castle the holding would be called Zaporozhie. Question, if title flags doesn't work, but traits do, have you tried character flags? would be a cleaner solution than traits for the reset-on reload, as long with an on_startup event to correct governments based on said flags, since on_startup also fire on Look at that particular vassals land while on the "government" type realm lens, is their land solid in color or is it stripey? How to rule over tribal holdings as Haestain Haesteining in the 867 start Update : On my way to finally reform the Roman Empire for the first time since ck2. They can be a baron, mayor, or bishop. A similar overlapping occurred in medieval scholasticism. Tribal rulers can only hold tribes without hey so im playing as saxony, reformed the germanic religion and became feudal. It completely throws off the logic and rhythm of the game and conquest becomes quite tiresome and annoying. If it's a Temple, unless your religion lets you directly control it, you're going to have to give it over to someone else. It seems that the new expansion is very strict about the government types and as a Feudal character a Tribal province needs to be my religion before it can be changed into a Castle as lithuania tribal there are none to raid, neighbours are the same poor b*tards. To have a tribe owned by a feudal vassal, you first need to have a feudal vassal, and then grant him the tribe. Questions on Ck2: How to fix "holder is of the wrong holding type" and how do I know who I am at war with? Depending on the number of empty holding slots in the county (minimum two slots), additional free holdings may be added to the ruler's demesne. IE: You have to fill all the empty holding slots before you can overwrite the tribe. Paragraph 1: Changing Government Types in Crusader Kings 2. No sub holdings, all at various stages of buildings but I dont think that matters. Also, they cannot be granted such holdings directly. . I build up all the castle towns in my capital duchy (two duchies in some cases), fill the remaining holding slots in my capital county with castles and max them with castle towns. effect = {province:4130={set_holding_type=castle_holding}} Replace 4130 with any province/barony level ID *null seems to glitch out the interface, and the title still exists, so id advise against that, changing the type seems to work fine though, but some visual glitch on the map)* well only if you're paying your way out of Tribal or Clan Government type is the form of government that a character lives under or rules by. However the problem still persists with it being the primary holding. When you as a ruler become feudal (or clan as Muslim) then the tribal holdings I’ve played multiple different tribal characters, and on all of them, I haven’t been able to build any holdings. Reply [deleted] • @Даня It doesn't seem to need any innovations. It's just a convenient game mechanic. If you give a holding to a landless character, they usually switch to whatever is the appropriate government type. I'd like to form into a republic, since there are You're not getting penalized for having the wrong government type, you're just not getting the bonus for empty holding slots that a tribal ruler would get. g if you are king, two kingdoms, if you are emperor two empires, etc) and a tribal holding. If you want more characters, go to the intrigue menu and use the decisions (e. Moving from one government type to another can unlock new gameplay options and expand your realm’s potential. Heresy is understood today to mean the denial of revealed truth as taught by the Church. 2 Platform Windows Additional Information Affected Feature Crashes; Gameplay; Save Game Hey yall, I recently got CK2 and am loving the game. In CK2 you could just build a new tribal holding in an empty barony then give away the castle holding to a baron. The Grand Mayor of Ulster keeps dying and the succesor keeps hating me after that because of this government type thing. After which you just convert to which government type and religion which suit your play CK2 The reason I ask is because a temple holding is the only holding it seems to be OK with being a pagan. feudal mechanics. I won it all complete. Tribes can upgrade to castles or cities, changing your government to either feudal or republic. Currently, the game doesnt really care that you are tribal when you conquer normal lands and simply gives you a standard "wrong holding" penalty or a "wrong government type The issue is that a tribal holding is a completely new type of holding which has no connection to the old-and-tested castle-church-city that we all know and love. " Then imprison the temple vassal from your one holding until he rebels; then imprison your heir until he rebels; and then accept the demands of your temple vassal. Reply [deleted] • Wrong government penalties mean you don't get much of either troops or taxes and they always join factions against their liege. You can farm these revolts for tons of prestige to spend on your tribal holdings. Would love some suggestions to keep the vassals under Hey, I used to play this game a lot and have just recently been getting back into it (I can never stay away) but I've been playing more tribal recently and have a question. Christian temples are called bishoprics, Muslim temples are called mosques, Zoroastrian temples are called vahrams, Hindu and Jain temples are called mandirs, while Buddhist temples are called viharas. There were always some methods to get control direct I received the "Nomad Agitation" warning indicating I needed to build a city or castle in the county. So what is the penalty for being feudal while holding a tribe county. Now i've got a "wrong holding" warning (because gotland started as a republic). There is a secondary holding which is a Castle. It is 882 AD and I am the King of Ireland and Scotland. However, when I click the next available holding slot "Build" next to Castle, City, and Temple are greyed out and it states "You must build one of each type of Holding first. What penalties, if any, are there for a wrong holding type? E. My Demesne levies took an insane hit (we're talking like 3k to 700 from the swap, the combination of only having one castle with no upgrades, the tribal places as wrong holding type and no more tribal armies around hurts like hell). The problem is that to become tribal I need to have a castle in my capital, but I am unable to upgrade my tribal holding to a castle (this option simply does not appear). com/Jugg Ck2 Change Government Cheat Second, it creates me with an unknow government type and and unknown title, so my character is, like, “unknowntitle Dalach Ua Doyle” which blows. I don't want width, I want depth. how can i fix that? after a quick google i read that i need to build a castle for them or something. Now this guy only has a city and he is grand mayor. These tribal vassals now hold a negative opinion of me due to 'wrong government type' and contribute minimal levies to me due to the tribal vs. This will change the county. The reason for this is the large penalty associated with owning a holding of the wrong type; you lose out on 75% of the income of the holding. Try to loot churches that give you some gold, develope your own holding with prestige points, if you are lucky you can capture in battle lord\chief who has enough gold to ransom himself. Hey, I used to play this game a lot and have just recently been getting back into it (I can never stay away) but I've been playing more tribal recently and have a question. You consolidate your holdings and then go feudal. Hindu characters will suffer opinion penalties if they have holdings which do not match their caste. If you do that, and the game speed is on SIX (important), your mayor heir will inherit your duke or king title and his city will become the primary holding of the county, and convert I recently went to war over a high chiefdom (4 county) area. The hillforst are still just reinforced. I'm a Norse Tribal Jarl, and captured a feudal county. Question, if title flags doesn't work, but traits do, have you tried character flags? would be a cleaner solution than traits for the reset-on reload, as long with an on_startup event to correct governments based on said flags, since on_startup also fire on Dear CK2 players, Somehow one of my county capitals is a city. In fact with the exception of baronies, giving the holding to a vassal instead will get So I was playing the demo earlier and an 'alert button' popped up saying that a few of my provinces were the wrong type of holding in my demesne. The tribal holding represents the entirety of the tribe in the county and the hill fort type city. Then you can select through the interface which holding you Tribal holdings cost to upgrade and if you give them to someone without land they become a chief and you get 30 point penalty for wrong government type. This is known as North Korea Mode. I have no interest in playing in India, I have no interest in tribal mechanics, and I don't want any nomad mechanics either. If B, you have to make a stone hillfort in your capital and then adopt feudalism and your primary holding will automatically upgrade to a castle. Tribal rulers can only hold tribes without You can probably give the county to the baron through the console (give_title c_county_id idOfBaronInCounty) and I don't think that will change who owns which holding, but will change which holding is the top holding. Tribal realms which seek to remain with the old ways may also pillage holdings they personally hold (like nomads), eventually freeing up the holding slot and making the tribe holding in the county more useful. I mean, they automatically all hate me because they're of the wrong government type. The Wrong Holding Type modifier now affects both tax and levies. Ck2 wrong holding type. Strangely, when playing a feudal lord with a tribal vassal, it requires you to build a temple and city prior to the tribal outpost (this is not the case if you are a tribal ruler building in your own direct county or tribal vassal's The problem with this is that it still wouldn't show the correct government in the lobby, but it could work in-gmae, yes. playing with a norse tribe, i want to conquer europe, but i cannot change the feudal holdings to my tribal goverment type. These are loosely ordered from easy to complex/historical to gaming the system. Imho it makes a lot sense that you get the wrong government type Wrong-government opinion penalties with feudal vassals. Claims can be checked by clicking on a character's portrait (they are shown one line above the owned titles, as COA with wide or thin green borders). Reply. I've noticed that the castle garrison is not refilling - is that just because of the New Administration penalty, or is garrison regeneration also being affected by the Wrong Holding Type penalty? I sat "eventually" because when you first convert your government your levies will be reduced significantly while your tribal holdings rebuild into castles. I guess this is due to the capital of the county being a city instead of a castle. Feb 10, 2012; Add bookmark #17 I have a question that I'm surprised I wasn't able to find an answer to online. Generally, feudal and tribal don't mix. At this point I am drowning in money compared to everyone else, it takes a good Ck2 tribal to feudal Ck2 tribal to feudal. I have the county of middlesex as a Feudal ruler, for some reasons there is a tribe in my desmenes i had to wait until the owner finally die at 77 to inherit it. So, is there a way to change a holding type to your goverment type? Without, it makes no sense to conquer other parts then northern realms. They are all tribes, and all different tribes. take whatever time you need to With the exception of tribal. It depends on your primary holding. Tribal rulers can only hold tribes without If A, you have to build a new castle and it will takeover as the primary holding since it is your correct type of holding and you can create a vassal for the old tribe. All of this can leave you exposed if you have stronger neighbors with As for whether it matters, I'll have to guess from CK2 again. Usually when you just conquered new lands you get this message, simply right. In short: 1) Assemble Mercs 2) tribal-improve holdings 3) send son to I am also getting the same problem. But you should save it until the last moment, preferably when your tribal holdings are developed. Menu. Inheriting a title, The Mayor holds his city directly, so you get 15% of the city's base income, instead of the count getting the default law's 30% and paying you 10% of that, or only 3% of base. The Bishopry still remains the primary holding in the county which gives it 1 more building slot and it also Early tribal you're supposed to steam roll your competition and make a kingdom. Tribal holdings cost to upgrade and if you give them to someone without land they become a chief and you get 30 point penalty for wrong government type. If it's a City, you're also going to have to give it away to a vassal, because you're not allowed to directly control cities. You can even hold all baronies yourself, although this has additional "wrong holding type" penalties for income/levies. Some of my counties will become cities and I get the "wrong type of holding" notification. Third, and perhaps worst, it creates some new provinces in Europe (okay) that are independent (hrm) and then makes them part of the Holy Roman Empire (record scratch). php?title=Wrong_type_of_holding&oldid=4780" This page Posted by u/Bjornvaldr - 4 votes and 7 comments In a case like this, if it's their first or only holding type, then they'll stay Feudal even if they're still unreformed pagan, and the castle will refill normally (but you can access it only as Tribalism is an early form of government, and one of three playable non-feudal government types in CK2 (the other two being merchant republics and nomadism. Your portion of the castle's levy is unaffected by the wrong gove type penalty, but the mayor's portion is, so if he rebels he'll be substantially weaker than a rebel count. Wrong settlement type [edit | edit source] Characters get a 75% penalty to income and levies in demesne settlements that do not match their government type. I try to correct it by using the create new vassal So, I'm the king of England. I don't think you even get any information of that. You can Fuedalize a tribal or clan holding for 500g, I think republics are always republics though. I've got a feudal Empire, and all of the core holdings upgraded to feudal when i took the title (i went for the North Sea Empire). Sort by stewardship. , I imprison/banish a mayor (as a king with one county), and take possession of his Paradox Forum. The problem with this is that it still wouldn't show the correct government in the lobby, but it could work in-gmae, yes. Strangely, when playing a feudal lord with a tribal vassal, it requires you to build a temple and city prior to the tribal outpost (this is not the case if you are a tribal ruler building in your own direct county or tribal vassal's It is considered a holding of the wrong type in Crusader Kings 3. 89 Badges. Barons have baronies, mayors have cities, and bishops have bishoprics. Diet of Worms Colonel. That's not it. I have already reformed the Germanic faith and am finishing up the last buildings in my tribal holdings. This only applies one-way; tribes under feudal lords do not mind (evidently not always true; research needed). 8/5/2019 So, I'm playing as tribal Scandinavia and am nearing the point where I'll have to decide whether I want to reform to become a republic or a feudal state. They will get a relations penalty for wrong government type but will give you vassal troops like a normal feudal vassal. You pick your character, and then you decide what your goals are - it's a sandbox, in much the same way that, say, Mount and Blade is a sandbox you've got a world, a framework, and rules to work within, and it's up to you to decide where to go and what to do with them. g. Being feudal or tribal is kind of like being feudal or republic, in that if you're a feudal lord holding tribal holdings they will produce crap income and levies and your tribal vassals will get a penalty for "wrong government type" until they manage to go feudal themselves. Unless you're playing as a Merchant Years later, my current king inherits the county and now I have the "Wrong type of Holding in Demesne" message. @Даня It doesn't seem to need any innovations. I own the county capital in Gwent, Caerwent, which is a castle and is apparently the wrong holding type for me. I started in Desmond, and quickly took control of Ormond. It would be a far better way of doing it. New posts CK2 Wiki said: If a character keeps a holding of the wrong type in their demesne, they will take a 75% penalty to income and levies You can change the primary holding type by granting the county title to a baron/mayor/bishop character in that county. The main holding would be a city. Event troops are disbanded as soon as all wars end declaring another war before concluding the first The Mayor holds his city directly, so you get 15% of the city's base income, instead of the count getting the default law's 30% and paying you 10% of that, or only 3% of base. You also want to make sure you have many of the secondary improvements to your tribal holdings before you change to feudal. What I’m wondering is, how do you tell who is a burgher and who is a noble? give them a tribe and they will rule it tribally. Every 2 levels of a tribal holding converts to In CK2, feudal rulers (including iqta, monastic feudal, Imperial, etc) can only hold tribal titles of their own culture without penalty. I went ahead and conquered the counties of old and new Volantis, but now I’m getting a penalty for wrong type of holding in demense. com/JuggernautYT?ty=hGive me a tad of your time and support the channel for free on TAD : http://givetad. I'm not sure why this happens, the only thing I can think of is that I build a level 1 market village in each county to boost my income. effect = {province:4130={set_holding_type=castle_holding}} Replace 4130 with any province/barony level ID *null seems to glitch out the interface, and the title still exists, so id advise against that, changing the type seems to work fine though, but some visual glitch on the map)* well only if you're paying your way out of Tribal or Clan A large part of your income, especially in a small realm, comes from the personal holdings of your demesne. I hope Stelaris is as good. Anyhow, i decided to yeet all my vassals I think my ruler is going to have to die now, but oh well, fuck it. And i cannot make any new vassals, so what is the problem? How do i fix it and keep the land myself? As a feudal ruler you can hold tribes without penalty if the province has the same culture as you, otherwise you will get a penalty. Weird Stuff MP State of Decay 2. The main ways you can go wrong are: Lamartine First Lieutenant. Im a duke now and to make a merchant republic I have heard I need to be a king, im assuming the negative opinion modifier for wrong holding type will disappear then so putting that aside Id like to know how to make a bishop the head of a province. Love the game. 13. Wrong type of holding in demesne I am the emperor of Rajastan (currently in northern India) and I built a city and a temple. Because whenever I assign a landed title I see the levy is decreased due You're not getting penalized for having the wrong government type, you're just not getting the bonus for empty holding slots that a tribal ruler would get. I don't know what version you are playing but in curent version Merchant Republics don't get wrong holding type warning for holding castles. They were tribal. I think it might only apply to county capital castles. the Base Income of the holding: 0. I don't want to waste my money upgrading them but I don't want the penalty either. If I want to stay a Germanic Help! This bs relationticker is killing my kingdom. "Each form of government has preferred and allowed settlements, and will get "Wrong government type" (-75% levies and income) penalty while holding other types of settlements directly. Sep 04, 2020 Government type is the form of government that a character lives under or rules. In a separate issue, I have towns/castles that I can't upgrade because it says I don't have Keeps II which I do have. Special decisions allow tribes and nomads to become more "settled". If I want to stay a Germanic I've read a few other similar posts for this, but can't find anything to work. Tribal and nomadic holdings have just the province name, and the primary holding name in parentheses. In CK2 you could simply build a tribal holding in an empty slot, which allowed to hold the county without penalties and build your necessary tribal buildings If there is a free slot in the county you can build a tribal holding if you are tribal as well and controll the county yourself. My understanding is that it means that the ruler's title does not correspond to the title of the holding. Sep 6, 2020 @ 11:57am So Vikings need to change all the cities to something else? If the vassal is getting the same error, then he shouldn't be sending me resources, but he is. This mod is a utility mod which allows to convert any of your existing holdings to what ever holding type you desire: Castle, City, or Temple. Either give it to an existing courtier or create a random new one out of thin air by right clicking on the Retrieved from "https://ck2. You pick the decision for the holding type you want. I doubt CK2 will get any update/patch even with added subscription thingy. Event troops are disbanded as soon as all wars end declaring another war before concluding the first Mod to remove 'Wrong Holding Type' Penalty. So where did it go wrong? Basically you need two top-tier titles (e. can anyone tell me how to I have all of Ireland right now (I'm also King of Eire), and I took over Gwynedd from the Petty Kingdom of Gwynedd, but now I have the wrong holding type in my demesne for some reason. value of a tribal holding depends Raiding is your best friend as a tribe. It advises assigning vassals to manage them properly. Apart from that, doesn't really matter if Choose wisely - give away weak and under-developed counties to your vassals, but keep the good ones to yourself. The county has a tribe and a temple built and 4 open holding slots. Your character is There are five types of settlements, each with a different set of buildings. It allows them to destroy these (and thus allow to improve both the taxes and levies of the Tribal Holding due to free settlements) at the cost of long time unrest (due to population displacement). can anyone tell me how to I'm told by my Situation report that I have holdings of the wrong type for my government, making them worthless as sources of tax and levies. Still only way to change the capital of the county is to revoke the holding you want to make a capital. Tribal rulers can only build temples and tribes 1. i have 40-60 vassals. Tribal rulers can only hold tribes without I don't have much experience with republics at all, so I'll give general advice. 15 rows Sep 04, 2020 Government type is the form of government that a character lives under. In fact I think 1 castle holding is actually weaker than 1 But it says wrong type of holding. There are four types of holdings: tribal, castle, cities, and temples. Latest. A red roll-over icon Good evening folks, I been playing this game for quite a while now, but even then there is always something you don't know. Am currently playing CK3 for the first time after like 2500 hours of CK2 In CK2 you would get crazy penalties like -75% income and negative demense limit if you were a tribal ruler holding feudal land. An analysis What went wrong with CK2 Islam, and suggestion how to improve it - DLC Idea - The Qabila - the islamic nomadic tribes my other CK2 DLC ideas: - Traders & Colonists - A Cultural and Trade enhancement for more flavourful peace time // Imperial bureaucratic government suggestion Hold on to the county and build that (nevermind the wrong type of holding warning, it's just that you'll get penalties on taxes and levies from that place). The penalty for holding a wrong-culture tribal title is that you get 75% less tax and levy from it, the same penalty for directly holding a city or temple. 3 were nomadic 1 was theocracy with tribe sub holding. thats 400 gold or something. It's not meant to represent the real world perfectly. I just won 3 counties in a war. This is known as Guantanamo Bay CK2 - I'm about to adopt Feudalism . Also, if you are not at your demesne limit you can hold onto wrong holdings. Wrong-holding-type penalties on feudal holdings you acquire. Since upgrading to feudal holdings requires level 1 castle tech, you Ck2 wrong holding type. Give a guy holding a king claim a barony while you're an emperor and that kingdom joins your realm if pressed. Jun 18, 2007 971 0. From what I understand, castles are best for levies, cities are best for tax, and temples are good at both, but give taxes to the Pope unless you have an anti_Pope and they like him more. When you start as tribal ruler you can only hold tribal and possibly temple holdings. Nomad -> Tribal seems to have almost no real incentive. You probably have a malus to their oppinion of you from "Wrong Government Type" or something, which reduces taxes and levy a bit. I Ignore the effects of demesne limits while holding all counties yourself. These settlements should generally be given to a vassal of the correct type or to a courtier (who will automatically take on the correct type). Usually I’d just give the counties away, but I obviously don Building holdings, especially cities pays off after a few centuries, so if you are in for the long haul it's a sensible decision, cities in particular are good for the long term as they make so much money they build all improvements on their own (even universities). If you grant someone a tribe as his first holding, his government becomes tribal unless it is somehow unavailable to him. I conquered some What exactly does this mean? Hopefully they'll address it at some point. Reply reply Top 1% Rank by size I'm feudal. What is the actual penalty for holding these? The author of this topic has Wrong type of holding in demense . I hold Leicester as Earl. I usually try and get a duchy I intend to use personally for the rest of the game asap. Even if you hand them off to someone else, see above. CK2. If your vasal holds wrong type of holding, it's his problem, not yours. Therefore, every count who holds this city gets a wrong holding type penalty of -30 (!) with me being a lord. Sadly, we will never know if this is a bug or it's working as intended. The main ways you can go wrong are: If they are of a different holding type, meaning they are in charge of a republic while you are a regular baron/duke or such, there is no way to get rid of the penalty short of changing your (or their) title over to the same kind of holding. correction: Character Types - There are three types that a character can be. since your vassals will remain tribal for a while and have lowered opinion of you due to wrong government type. In fact with the exception of baronies, giving the holding to a vassal instead will get Probably not what you're looking for but I got turned tribal after getting the crusader kingdom of Egypt and having a tribal holding as my capital. Or with the Horse Lords expansion I believe you could completely raze the territory if you were nomadic. It gives you both gold and prestige, which you need to build improvements to your holdings and to summon tribal armies. I can take the barony and make if the county capital, but the duchy building slot stays Give it to a vassal. I'm thinking of letting that go until I can get their hillfort up to stone and then change to castle. Out of the 3 previously nomadic counties, only two show up as wrong holding type. It seems that the new expansion is very strict about the government types and as a Feudal character a Tribal province needs to be my religion before it can be changed into a Castle Give a barony to someone. By capturing only one castle and squashing the rest of the armies, you could sometimes force a peace. So I did just that, and experienced an immediate income drop! Opening up the build-menu in each holding I can't see what' so unusual about them. Allmänt. Holding Income = (Base Income + Building Income) x (1 + Local Income Modifiers) x (1 + Owner Income Modifiers) The Base Holding Income is the sum of: . Cannot be cancelled. xyrlsm uwk zmlpm cbd bvbgal zsj cujyrr jmzjh mxuljj eezy